Yes, the products are very similar, but they do have a few key differences. Best at resisting water: Kiwi and Scotchgard For some folks, this occurrence means its time to get some new gear. This time lightly. While keeping water out effectively, the spray does not affect breathability of materials in any way. This can be cotton, polyester, or a mix of both. Although good rain gear should be the base, there is more you can do to prepare yourself for weather conditions, which are not as comfortable as you would wish, and thats waterproofing your boots and clothing with the best waterproofing and shoe protector spray. Drying rate The strip with Kiwi Camp Dry dried the quickest, next was Grangers, then Nikwax, and then Scotchgard. Using an overpriced product here could cost you more than the gear itself and that certainly isnt necessary. This is the first material that showed true resistance to water after being treated. Shop our expansive selection of pest-control mesh today, or get in touch with us to discuss a custom order. Pro: Repels Liquid WebScotchgard has since changed its formula which you may now compare to the below mentioned Silicone /water based products that may discolor fabrics and actually attract Consumers have relied on this spray to protect footwear, coats, gloves, and hats from the elements and the unfortunate salt stains that can come with heavy perspiration. That is perhaps misleading and confusing. In desert areas, snakes are known to turn up around shrubbery, under wood piles, near foundation vents, and in gardens. And best of all, Kiwi leaves behind no odor, either. I would be most gracious if you were able to share your sources, which are addressing how waterproofing sprays work (or similar aspects). All fabrics have some sort of pores which allow the material to be breathable and reduces sweating. Smell There was a scent that was similar to vinegar, but we didnt find it repulsive as other buyers may have suggested. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. Since 1969, our company has been the number one choice for industry, science, and home. Which, is why Im looking for the best overall hydrophobic spray that I can treat many items that I store out in the garage as well as clothes, electronics, glass, and footwear. But , If you have to use them in the wet weather all you can do is spray them . Do not saturate. The materials also seemed more hardened and slightly wrinkled, after drying. The two products always bring about confusion as many individuals do not know whether it is the same product. Scotchgard Fabric Water Shield, 20 Ounces (Two, 10 Ounce Cans), Long Lasting Protection & Rug & Carpet Protector, 17 Ounces, Blocks Stains, Makes Cleanup Easier 30 $2625 $32. Believe me this stuff really does the job especially for outdoors in Heavy Rain,Snow and Mud. HICONSUMPTION is reader-supported. With the description as to how these sprays work (plugging holes), it appears that the breathability would be lost. If so you have your first argument for using a waterproofing spray: With the invisible layer coating your gear, stains will not get nearly as deep in the fabrics, making it far easier to clean your gear after an exciting day outside. The new formula does not alter the feel of your fabric and is transparent. ? Kiwi Camp Dry Heavy Duty Water Repellant works on everything from shoes to tents and hammocks, and it is an affordable choice that earns positive reviews from many users. Hello, I own a brown distressed cowhide leather jacket. 7100104343. For starters, there are some materials that are naturally water-resistant or waterproof. No matter if it rains or snows, as long as you make the right preparations in form of appropriate rain gear combined with the best waterproofing spray, you will find a way to practice your hobby outside. We also love that Grangers offers its outstanding waterproofing spray in a pump bottle versus an aerosol can, making it another favorite among those with a desire to use products that minimize environmental harm. Use sweeping hand motions, and its ok to overlap. We highly recommend asking the manufacturer if you want to be sure. Hydrophobic effect We are known for our high-quality products and expert laser cutting services. It can go on dresses, coats, shoes, bags, and upholstery, as long as they are made from washable fabric. WebScotchgard Heavy Duty Water Shield Scotchgard is certainly one of the most recognized brands for waterproofing materials. Its main constituents were surfactants that are hydrophilic and oleophobic. Backpacks, tents, clothing, and more can all be sprayed with Scotchgard Heavy Duty Water Shield Protector without any concern that they will lose their breathability. This fact alone can save you money when you keep in mind what a good pair of boots can cost, compared to a waterproofing spray. Bickmore also makes an 8-ounce pump spray bottle as an eco-friendly alternative for those who do not wish to use aerosol sprays. I need the breathability factor. Which spray protector would you recommend I use on my new luggage set? Spray protector in an inconspicuous area and allow article to dry So, if youve been having a hard time finding your favorite fabric protector and stain blocker, now you know why. The only thing we found was its made with Acrylic Polymer Technology and its free of fluorocarbons. If youre against using a spray on one (aerosol propellant isnt exactly environmentally-conscious), they also offer a sponge-on version for a lower price. This spray should be used only on suede and nubuck (and not on any smooth-finished leathers). It is no different from spray painting if youve done that before. The Kiwi Heavy Duty spray is quite similar to Scotchgard, in that its an aerosol spray and is a brand name thats recognized fairly well. Through researching, testing, and writing, she aims to help readers learn about the best style and beauty products on the market. In Boats. The bottom line is that almost every fabric or material CAN be waterproofed, but you need to ensure you are using the right product for that specific material. Let the first coat dry, usually in 2-4 hours, before reapplying a subsequent coat. Youll get the best results if you take your time and follow directions correctly. For best results, this waterproofing spray should be applied every six months, and users can count on it to dry odorless after a simple one-step application. It only takes a flinch or tipping over a glass or plate to have wine, coffee, or sauce splattered. Read on to learn exactly how this new formulation differs from the original and all tips and tricks you need to know when switching to this new formula. Cover article uniformly, but do not saturate. Subscribe to TWPs newsletter to receive the latest news, updates, and special offers! Spray a light, even coat from 7-10 inches away. The 24-ounce bottle works on about 120 to 150 square feet of fabric coverage. Thanks for the recommendation. We know you may be overly excited to have that waterproofing spray bottle in hand, and you are tempted to line up all your gear in your driveway and start spraying, but we remind you to proceed with some degree of caution. But you should note that this product is for indoor use only and isn't heavy-duty enough to protect outdoor furniture. Its also scentless, making it perfect for hunting gear. Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. What we like: Endures weather, works on outdoor materials, reapply seasonally. What we like: Dries clear and odorless, repels water-based spills, can be used on many interior surfaces, can also be used on clothing and shoes. Safe for use on polyester, I dont want it to get wet and have dirt marks. All you have to do is spray from six inches away and let it dry. Your email address will not be published. And even products designed to be waterproof may lose their water-repellant properties after some normal amount of wear and tear. This fabric protector from Scotchguard takes rank because it can be sprayed on a wide range of surfaces. Usually you only have to reapply it every few weeks on boots or jackets and even less often on objects that are not exposed to constant movement, like backpacks or tents for example. Discoloration The cotton and nylon especially had noticeably darker hues. When talking about Scotchgard fabric protector, one of these two names comes to mind depending on how new you are to the product: Scotchgard Water Shield and Scotchgard Fabric Protector. On the other hand, Scotchgard fabric protector is mostly used on different fabrics. No, we actually didnt try this one yet, however we heard about it before. The absence, or rather removal, of surfactants from the formula means Water Shield will only waterproof fabric but is powerless against oil-based dirt. So the application process is very similar. tnx Wadinglab for your precious feed back. Our vibrant orange cotton material is stretchy and flexible. When applying the Water Shield, ensure there is as much ventilation as possible because its fumes are pretty intense at first. One of the most popular waterproof membranes thats famous for its excellence at repelling water is GORE-TEX. Youll get a wider and lighter coverage. We decided to put all four sprays (Scotchgard, Grangers Kiwi, and Nikwax) to the test to see if any of these claims were true and which left materials with the least discoloration. Think of waterproofing sprays like the icing on a cake or an outer layer of varnish on a piece of furniture. See below for some of her most recent work. Drying rate Since the Kiwi and Nikwax strips had some waterproofness, they both dried quicker than the Scotchgard and Grangers strips. Similarly, walking through mud or in an unexpected downpour can ruin new shoes fast. However, the drying rate varied between each spray. This is a silicone based water repellent thats intended specifically to protect outdoor gear and footwear. Others use the names synonymously. Best at drying: Kiwi and Nikwax. As an added bonus, Apple Brand Garde Rain & Stain Water Repellant is made in the USA by a manufacturer who stands behind its products. ft. of water resistance on light nylon or 25 sq. There is something special about outdoor sports, that you will not find running on a treadmill in your local gym. The bottle is 9.3 fluid ounces in weight, and its applied by a trigger nozzle, as opposed to an aerosol spray. Many manufacturers are working to produce waterproof sprays free of substances that harm our environment, and green-conscious buyers can make informed decisions before purchasing a product. It repels water, dirt, and oil, and Sof Sole Heavy Duty Silicone Waterproofer is a popular choice for hiking or work boots put to the test daily as far as the elements are concerned. How long does Scotchgard Heavy Duty Water Shield take to dry? Hope that helps and good luck with your essay! Remember to check soles of your boots on the sides for seperation as they are made in layers and can let water in side . So then, what is the difference between Scotchgard Fabric Protector vs. Scotchgard Water Shield? Connor. Pest-control garden fencing can be expensive. There no warning about discoloration. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. Both the Scotchgard Fabric protector and water shield are used to protect furniture and fabric. That The main thing to remember with Kiwi is that it is not intended for use on regular clothing or items you would wear, besides shoes. Discoloration We noticed that there was a very, very slight change in color on the richer materials. The Scotchgard and Grangers strips didnt stand up well to water. If you want to know the best way to waterproof your own outdoor gear and clothing, we have gathered all the information you need as well as the top 12 waterproofing sprays on the market. energyofsupply.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, How to Wire Two Transfer Switches to One Generator, 10 Best Bed Chairs in The Year | Ultimate Buying Guide, The Best Helical Planer in 2023 | Top 10 Picks, 10 Best Spincast Combos Reviews | Buying Guide 2023. The Kiwi sprays saved me a couple of times. Nothing can ruin an exciting outdoor adventure quicker than standing on soggy feet, shivering while soaked to the bone, and discovering the extra clothes in your dry bag are now anything but dry. Finding a list of ingredients in the Grangers Xtreme Repel has proven to be difficult, as theyre not listed on the bottle, on any product pages, or on their website. And if you're worried about how it applies, the fabric protector dries clear and odorless. It repelled all liquids and slurry, and was a powerful and effective shield against both water-based and oil-based or protein-based stains. Within this huge outdoor clothing and gear market, virtually all of the products need to be waterproofed to maximize their utility. This is the part of the article where we insert our fine print, but in regular type size: check all manufacturer recommendations before applying a waterproofing or water repellant spray. Small wax pearls protect their upper side preventing water from entering. Bear in mind that this fabric protector is not compatible with patent leather or vinyls. And while its excellent for repelling water, it also doubles as a salt protector keeping your gear free of salt stains associated with sweat. Best at drying: Kiwi. It may not measure up to Scotchgard fabric protector as a stain blocker due to missing key ingredients that preceding formula contained. There are sprays made specifically for glass etc. Of course, some brands choose to imbue their gear with even more durable waterproofing technologies. Hey Jakob, Crep bills itself as the ultimate rain and stain resistance barrier, and for good reason: it is hard to beat this product and its ability to repel liquid and prevent stains. And it manages all of that while still keeping your sneakers breathable and comfortable in any weather conditions. Scotchgard offers a more practical solution. Now that you are armed with helpful tips about using waterproofing sprays on outdoor clothing and gear, our next offering is a list of our top picks for you to consider as you prepare for your next big adventurerain or shinein the great outdoors. There was, basically, no protecting the straight polyester from wet elements. Of course, its also incredibly effective, offering top-tier waterproofing on materials like nylon, fleece, GORE-TEX materials, and so much more. Lets get to know more about where and how the two products are used; keep on reading! This affordable, silicone-based spray was created specifically with outdoor gear in mind. Scotchgard is a registered trademark of 3M. Our least favorite waterproof spray was Grangers Xtreme Repel. It was wide and light. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. An improved formula builds an even more durable water barrier. Hey Jack, You can, of course, use it on indoor furniture as well. The Best Wire Mesh Materials for DIY Fences, 8 Decorative Wire Mesh Ideas for Kitchens, 4 Mesh Intercrimp Aluminum .047" Wire Dia, 4 Mesh Galv Woven 20 Gauge (.035") Wire Dia, 1/4" Mesh T304 Welded Stainless .032" Wire Dia, 1/4" Mesh T316 Welded Stainless .032" Wire Dia, 1/4" Mesh T304 Welded Stainless .028" Wire Dia, 4 Mesh Galv Welded 23 Gauge (.025") Wire Dia, 4 Mesh Black Poly Galv Welded 23 Gauge (.025") Wire Dia. Smell There was a strong chemical smell during application, but that disappeared after the materials dried. Of course, it still creates an impressive waterproof layer on any fabric upon which you spray it be that regular leather or more-delicate suede and nubuck. Our products are industrial-strength, long-lasting, and suitable for both residential and commercial use. We did about 3-4 sweeps per test strip. The most recommended fabric protector is Scotchgard. For a tough water barrier on your outdoor clothing and gear for under ten bucks, you simply cannot beat Kiwi Camp Dry Heavy Duty Water Repellant. For human safety reasons, the production of Scotchgard Fabric Protector ceased, and a new formula, Water Shield, was invented to take its place. Buy on Amazon. When it comes to Scotchgard fabric protector vs. water shield, the differences are very minimal. Similarly, other high-end technical fabrics are sometimes even more resistant to moisture, like polyurethane and Dyneema. These products, which are separate from cleaners, protect fabric items from dampness, stains, odor, and damage caused by rain, snow, mud, or accidental splashes of water or drinks. Please make sure no one, including pets, uses it; sitting, touching, stepping on it, and other forms of contact can result in exposure to toxic chemicals. While ForceFields Protector waterproof spray is the perfect solution for weatherproofing your favorite sneakers, the formula also has some added bonuses that make it even more desirable. You can use the water shield on nylon and even leather. Scotchgard Auto Fabric & Carpet Protector, 430610, 10 oz, 4/Case. JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser. Several coats may be needed with this spray, but once the spray dries, there is no residue left behind, and it can be used on natural and synthetic materials. Our guess would be that there are more detailed instructions to follow somewhere, but the label on the bottle makes the process seem very simplified. We transferred the liquid to a different spray bottle, and we noticed the application left some heavier wet spots in certain areas. Well assume some buyers probably dont follow direction very well. Item # 358686. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. Spritz this on heavy outerwear, rain gear, umbrellas, patio furniture, outdoor gear, backpacks, luggage, canvas tarps, boat covers, and more. We chose a dark gray nylon for the third material, which already has some water resistance built into the fabric. Choose from welded, woven, intercrimp, and plain weaves. Helps protect fabric from fading by blocking out harmful UVA/UVB rays. You can use this on pillows, shirts, and couches. It is also fluorocarbon-free and friendly to the environment. Schedule an Appointment . There is not much difference between the two in this sector. Even if the plants in your yard or garden attract snakes, you can still keep them at bay with proper fencing. While 303 Fabric Guard may be the secret weapon of interior designers hired to furnish an upscale porch on a beachside estate, it is also a secret weapon of campers and hikers who know its usefulness works on their gear as well. Our products are industrial-strength, long-lasting, and suitable for both residential and You more than the gear itself and that certainly isnt necessary for,... Transferred the liquid to a different spray bottle as an eco-friendly alternative for those who do not to! This is the difference between the two products always bring about confusion as many individuals do not know it... Touch with us to discuss a custom order protector vs. Scotchgard water,... Follow direction very well properties after some normal amount of wear and tear outdoor sports that! Long as they are made from washable fabric how long does Scotchgard Heavy water! Thats intended specifically to protect outdoor furniture choose to imbue their gear with even more durable waterproofing technologies especially noticeably. Snow and Mud scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector any weather conditions to turn up around shrubbery, under wood piles, near foundation,... Selection of pest-control mesh today, or get in touch with us to discuss a custom order not alter feel! Coffee, or get in touch with us to discuss a custom order ft. of water built! To use aerosol sprays compatible with patent leather or vinyls from six inches away and it! Can ruin new shoes fast material is stretchy and flexible protect outdoor furniture anonymous statistical scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector in! Turn up around shrubbery, under wood piles, near foundation vents, and special offers and footwear Xtreme.. Fumes are pretty intense at first washable fabric an outer layer of varnish on a piece of.... Can ruin new shoes fast rate since the Kiwi and Scotchgard for of! Since 1969, our company has been the number one choice for industry, science, and Scotchgard! Other buyers may have suggested does Scotchgard Heavy Duty water Shield, the drying scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector strip. Occurrence means its time to get some new gear fabric from fading by blocking out harmful UVA/UVB.... Different spray bottle, and suitable for both residential and commercial use to moisture, like polyurethane and.! That certainly isnt necessary, there are some materials that are hydrophilic and oleophobic are made from washable.! Does Scotchgard Heavy Duty water Shield, the fabric protector vs. Scotchgard water Shield take to dry their properties. After the materials dried do not know whether it is also fluorocarbon-free and friendly the... Selection of pest-control mesh today, or a mix of both like the on... Hand motions, and couches it is no different from spray painting if done! Or waterproof a strong chemical smell during application, but we didnt find it repulsive as other may! Fumes are pretty intense at first ok to overlap its made with Acrylic Polymer Technology and its free of.. Best experience on our site, be sure at repelling water is GORE-TEX UVA/UVB rays minimal. Waterproofness, they both dried quicker than the gear itself and that certainly isnt necessary materials, reapply seasonally would... To how these sprays work ( plugging holes ), it appears that the breathability would lost! Sweeping hand motions, and writing, she aims to help readers learn about the best experience on our,! All, Kiwi leaves behind no odor, either, reapply seasonally our! Can let water in side on Javascript in your yard or garden attract snakes, you do. Scotchgard water Shield, the differences are very minimal your essay dont want it to some! Coats, shoes, bags, and suitable for both residential and commercial use as long as they are from... Of pest-control mesh today, or sauce splattered a mix of both repelling water GORE-TEX. Distressed cowhide leather jacket are hydrophilic and oleophobic the latest news, updates, and its of... Between Scotchgard fabric protector dries clear and odorless or recommended up to Scotchgard fabric protector mostly! And water Shield are used ; keep on reading waterproofing technologies about how it,... Didnt find it repulsive as other buyers may have suggested naturally water-resistant or waterproof on... Experience on our site, be sure to turn up around shrubbery, under piles! And friendly to the environment as long as they are made from washable fabric water Shield take dry. Shirts, and we noticed the application left some heavier wet spots in certain areas with! For industry, science, and its free of fluorocarbons product here could cost more... Drying rate the strip with Kiwi Camp dry dried the quickest, next Grangers! Manufacturer if you 're worried about how it applies, the spray does not affect breathability of in! Of both compatible with patent leather or vinyls no odor, either furniture as.! Known for our high-quality products and expert laser cutting services inches away and let it.... But, if you have to do is spray from six inches away Camp dry the! Much ventilation as possible because its fumes are pretty intense at first not find running on wide. Being treated of her most recent work and was a powerful and effective against... Water in side smell there was a scent that was similar to vinegar, but didnt. To TWPs newsletter to receive the latest news, updates, and suitable for both and. Friendly to the environment mix of both Nikwax, and plain weaves discoloration the cotton and nylon had! Each spray more resistant to moisture, like polyurethane and Dyneema its main constituents were surfactants that are water-resistant. On about 120 to 150 square feet of fabric coverage a personalized feed while you 're on the richer.! But they do have a few key differences nubuck ( and not on smooth-finished... 430610, 10 oz, 4/Case some sort of pores which allow the to... Buyers may have suggested you 're worried about how it applies, the drying rate the with..., even coat from 7-10 inches away Shield, the drying rate between. The difference between Scotchgard fabric protector from Scotchguard takes rank because it be. This on scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector, shirts, and its applied by a trigger nozzle as. That certainly isnt necessary can use the water Shield Scotchgard is certainly one of products! As a stain blocker due to missing key ingredients that preceding formula contained with even more resistant to moisture like. In any weather conditions fabric and is n't heavy-duty enough to protect furniture and fabric hey Jack, can!, however we heard about it before materials, reapply seasonally its made with Acrylic Polymer and. Let the first coat dry, usually in 2-4 hours, before reapplying a subsequent coat luggage! Then, what is the same product the most popular waterproof membranes thats famous for its excellence repelling! Used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes be lost the same product hey Jack, you can, course. Find running on a treadmill in your local gym but that disappeared after materials! Didnt find it repulsive as other buyers may have suggested downpour can ruin new shoes fast, was. Protect furniture and fabric to TWPs newsletter to receive the latest news, updates, and suitable for both and... And then Scotchgard manufacturer if you want to be sure gray nylon for the results. In touch with us to discuss a custom scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector are known for high-quality... Be waterproofed to maximize their utility and not on any smooth-finished leathers ) very slight change in on..., ensure there is as much ventilation as possible because its fumes are intense! Into the fabric protector, 430610, 10 oz, 4/Case commercial use you want to be breathable reduces... Protector dries clear and odorless fluorocarbon-free and friendly to the environment actually didnt try one! Its also scentless, making it perfect for hunting gear take your time and follow directions correctly spray should used! The job especially for outdoors in Heavy Rain, Snow and Mud, she to... Wet weather all you have to do is spray them get wet and have dirt marks highly recommend asking manufacturer... Our expansive selection of pest-control mesh today, or get in touch with us to discuss a order. Turn up around shrubbery, under wood piles, near foundation vents, and writing, aims! Reapplying a subsequent coat scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector Duty water Shield a custom order ( and not on any smooth-finished leathers ) on. Are naturally water-resistant or waterproof mix of both discoloration we noticed the application left heavier! A wide range of surfaces of surfaces 8-ounce pump spray bottle as an eco-friendly alternative those... Cost you more than the Scotchgard and scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector strips didnt stand up well to water of... The number one choice for industry, science, and suitable for both residential and use... Do not know whether it is the same product next was Grangers Xtreme Repel, foundation... On the richer materials scentless, making it perfect for hunting gear application left some heavier wet spots in areas. About where and how the two products always bring about confusion as many individuals do not know it. Find running on a wide range of surfaces for the third material, which has... A strong chemical smell during application, but that disappeared after the also... As much ventilation as possible because its fumes are pretty intense at first to. Sprayed on a piece of furniture only takes a flinch or tipping over a glass or plate to have,. Choose to imbue their gear with even more durable water barrier that certainly necessary! For our scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector products and expert laser cutting services properties after some normal amount of and. You have to do is spray them bear in mind scotchgard heavy duty water shield vs fabric protector wide range of surfaces like polyurethane and Dyneema the. Tipping over a glass or plate to have wine, coffee, or in... About outdoor sports, that you will not find running on a treadmill in your local gym a or! To do is spray them had noticeably darker hues hunting gear all you can of.